Gas or Wood? Picking a Fire Pit for Cool Nights Around Lake Chatuge

One lights with a match and some patience. The other lights with a knob. Here is how to pick the fire you will really use.

5 min read

ALC OutdoorsOwner-led by Shawn Gallagher. 25+ years of outdoor work around Lake Chatuge.
Talk to usCall (678) 965-9616 or text (678) 599-4441→

Short summary

  • Wood gives you the crackle, the smell and the most heat. It also gives you smoke, ash and a little work.
  • Gas lights in seconds and shuts off just as fast, with no smoke. It needs a fuel line or a tank and costs more to set up.
  • Pick the one that matches how you live. The best fire pit is the one that gets lit on a plain old Tuesday.

Up here the evenings cool off fast, even in summer. The sun drops behind the ridge, the lake goes still, and somebody always says it: “We should have a fire.”

A built-in fire pit makes that easy. But before the first stone goes down, there is one big choice to make. Gas or wood? Both are good. They are just good at different things.

The case for wood

Wood is the classic. It pops. It smells like camping. It throws real heat, the kind that warms your knees and your face at the same time. And there is something about poking a fire with a stick that never gets old, no matter how old you get.

Wood is also simple. There is no line to run and nothing to hook up. You need a pit, dry wood and a match.

The trade-offs are small but real. Smoke follows somebody around the circle, and it is always the same person. There is ash to scoop. And a wood fire takes a little time to start and a little time to die down, so it is not a ten-minute thing.

Round fire pit patio set in a lawn under a big sky
A round wood-burning pit with open space all around it. Simple and hard to beat.

The case for gas

Gas is the easy button. Turn a knob and you have flame. Turn it back and you are done. No smoke in your hair, no ash, no waiting for coals to go out before bed.

That ease changes how often you use it. A gas fire is the one you light for twenty minutes with a cup of coffee. It is the one you light on a weeknight. For a lot of families, easy means more fires.

The trade-offs: gas needs fuel. That is either a line run to the pit or a tank tucked out of sight. It costs more to set up. And the flame is pretty, but it does not throw heat quite like a pile of burning oak.

Fire, a few ways

Round, square, long and low.

Fire pits come in a lot of shapes. These clips are here for ideas, not from our own jobs.

Five questions that pick for you

Not sure yet? These usually settle it.

  1. How often will you light it? A few big nights a year points to wood. A few nights a week points to gas.
  2. Who is using it? If you want kids roasting marshmallows over real coals, that is wood.
  3. How close is the house? Smoke and sparks need room. Gas is easier to live with on a smaller patio.
  4. Where is the fuel? If gas is already at the house, a line may be simple. If not, a tank can do the job.
  5. Do you love the ritual? Some folks love building a fire. Some folks love not building a fire. Be honest.

The best fire pit is the one that gets lit on a plain old Tuesday.

What both kinds need

Here is the part that is the same either way. A good fire pit is a small piece of masonry, and it needs what all masonry needs.

  • A solid base. We set the pit ring and any seat wall on a solid base, so it stays level and does not settle.
  • A safe surface around it. Pavers around the pit give you a clean spot for chairs and keep sparks off the grass.
  • The right spot. We size and place it with clearances in mind, away from the house and low branches, and we talk it through with you.
  • Somewhere to sit. A built-in seat wall means there is always a seat, even when the chairs are on the porch.
Round stone fire pit on a paver patio beside a low stone wall on a wooded lake lot, built by ALC Outdoors
Our workA fire pit patio we built on a lake lot, with a stone wall behind it and the woods all around.

The payoffA reason to stay outside a little longer.

A quick word about firewood

If you go with wood, the wood matters as much as the pit. Dry, seasoned hardwood lights easier, burns hotter and makes far less smoke than wood that was cut last month. Wet wood hisses, smokes and sulks.

Keep a small stack off the ground and under cover, close to the pit. A simple rack by the seat wall does the job and looks good doing it.

Can you have both?

Sort of. Some families put a gas fire table up close on the patio for easy weeknights, and a simple wood pit farther out in the yard for the big nights. It is two fires for two moods. If you have the room, it is a lovely way to go.

If you have to pick one, picture a real evening. It is a Thursday. You are tired. Do you still want a fire? If the answer is “only if it is easy,” you have your answer.

Fire season on the lake

Around Lake Chatuge the fire pit is not just a fall thing. Spring evenings are cool. Summer nights drop into sweater weather once the sun leaves the water. And fall, with the color on the ridges above Hiawassee and Young Harris, is the best of all.

We build round pits, square pits, gas and wood, with seat walls and paver surrounds that match the patio. Tell us how you picture your evenings, and we will help you pick the fire that fits. Then all that is left is the marshmallows, and you are on your own there.

Questions people ask

Is gas or wood better for a fire pit?

Neither is better for everyone. Wood gives more heat and the classic feel. Gas is faster, cleaner and easier to use often. We can build either one.

Can you match my patio?

Yes. We tie the fire pit and seat wall into your existing pavers and stone, or build it all together.

Is a fire pit safe near the house?

We size and place it with clearances in mind and build it solid. We will talk through placement with you before anything is built.

Can a fire pit have built-in seating?

Yes. A seat wall around part of the pit is one of the most popular things we add. It gives you seating that is always there.

Around Lake Chatuge · Hiawassee, Young Harris, Hayesville

Want a fire pit the whole family uses?

Tell us what you have in mind. We will take a look and talk it through with you, plain and simple.

Call the office or text the cell. A couple of photos of your yard help us help you faster.